Friday, December 3, 2010

If it's free, what's in it for me?

The misunderstanding that humans only do things because they provide some kind of financial reward is a frequent point of debate around the Zeitgeist Movement.  I cannot remember the source, but I remember reading a few months back about a study that demonstrated that financial rewards do not inspire greater creativity in a person's work. In fact, a financial incentive was only efficacious in its effect of increasing productivity in jobs that require a lot of repetitive behaviors (which are usually the lowest paid jobs).

So, I was wondering about the people around me. What kinds of things do they not only do for free, but they may also do them at their own financial loss?  (To protect their privacy, I will refer to them generally.)

Whether investing in photography equipment, rock and gem instruments, or culinary supplies, these people do so at their own loss.  One person spends several hundred dollars to create a piece of art even when there is no intention of making some future profit.  This art is created and mounted for the pure pleasure of its expression.  A feast is prepared and shared for the fulfillment of sharing.  The rocks and gems are inspected and measured for the enrichment of learning.  Pictures are taken with utmost care for the honor of immortalizing nature's beauty.  Information is shared in the hopes that such information will mobilize people to change a condition that is causing suffering.  Some people don't have a loss of their own physical resources, but they offer their time and energy to help make people feel better.

The internet is full of contributions from people who have no monetary reward.  I was playing a video game recently and I had some trouble progressing. I went looking online for a solution and there wasn't just one......there were dozens of discussions, video posts, written posts and other recommendations about just one problem! I wondered, "why would anyone spend the time to do all this work for nothing?"  Because they like to.  While it is possible to get a bit of fame and ride that wave to some financial reward from a contribution to the internet, the probability is very low.

What's really surprising is that even in an environment of wage slavery and "time is money," we still have people who produce, create, share, and just plain do for the simple fact that they want to do it.  It's even more surprising that people do these things at their own financial peril.  After all, they could be saving all that money and investing in something that will earn them more money!

As I see it, the monetary system, which creates financial reward in a context of scarcity, is really an oppressing force.  In reading some comments/blogs from people who are unemployed, I am surprised to read how many people come to the point of "I might as well use my time for something I've always wanted to do, but never had the time to do it."  They may not get paid, but many of them are contributing in a healthy way to create a healthier society.  If people weren't stuck in jobs that were either 1. meaningless outside of a monetary paradigm or  2. not in line with their actual interests and talents, we would have an outpouring of contributions from individuals who've been oppressed for so long under the Monetary Regime.

Please share your comments of people you know who engage in activities without the reward of money.

3 comments:

  1. This is the money vs motivation thing you were thinking of...
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u6XAPnuFjJc

    ReplyDelete
  2. The reality is that Humans survive because of our cooperation in almost every aspect of life. Someone brings food to the store, and someone else hauls away our trash, and someone else cares for our health from a vast amount of knowledge that they have spend uncounted hours learning... the 'motivation' is moot. What happens in the real is the true result. Money and most of the aspects of society that cause our problems are purely conceptual, in our heads, and a 'crust' like rust on the surface of the shiny metal of human cooperation.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thanks Dave for that link. I had only read about the research, but this was very entertaining and informative.

    Roan, please continue to sandblast away that rust and let the shiny metal show its natural brilliance.

    ReplyDelete